Volume 620 pages
About the book
Is an act right because of the will behind it, or because of the happiness it brings? This volume, the first in the series Antinomies, stages the two best-known answers as one book-debate in eight rounds. In each round John Stuart Mill speaks first and Immanuel Kant second, on a single question: where morality begins, what its supreme principle is, whether happiness can found it, what moves and binds us, whether the first principle can be proved, what we owe to others, what a moral philosophy leaves out, and whether duty and happiness meet at last. Mill's Utilitarianism and Kant's Fundamental Principles are given complete, with Mill's essays on Bentham and Whewell, his chapter on the logic of practice, and large parts of Kant's two later ethical works, in Abbott's translation. A comparison, a chronology and notes close the book. The apparatus takes no side.